Review: John Terborgh on the Insect Apocalypse
Last week we considered the work of Rachel Carson, whose 1962 book Silent Spring sounded the alarm about the danger of pesticide use and is sometimes credited with launching the modern environmental movement. Today we hear from John Terborgh, a senior scholar and researcher on tropical ecology and conservation, that our assault on insect life remains a potentially catastrophic threat to natural systems.
A large study carried out in sixty-three German nature reserves between 1989 and 2016 revealed a stunning 75 percent decrease in the mass of captured insects within the study’s boundaries. Dave Goulson’s new book, Silent Earth: Averting the Insect Apocalypse, is a timely and important work documenting these breathtaking declines in insect abundance. The author writes from the vantage of his own corner of the world, the United Kingdom, but evidence that insects are vanishing globally is coming in from North America, Europe, Puerto Rico, and elsewhere.
Why we should care about insects? Most broadly, because biodiversity is insect diversity: there are more species of insects than of all other organisms combined. It would be enough to weigh the interests of insects themselves, but insects also perform many vital functions in the larger ecology. These include the pollination of a majority of the plant species on earth, the dispersal of seeds, the processing of organic matter that recycles nutrients to the soil, and the regulation of other populations through predation and parasitism. Most crucially for us vertebrates, insects and their arthropod kin provide sustenance for innumerable mammals, reptiles, amphibians, and birds. Without insects, much of the rest of nature would collapse. We may already be seeing signs of that collapse in the estimate that North America has lost three billion birds over the last half century, 30 percent of the 1970 population.
Why is this happening? There are many potential reasons, each the subject of a chapter in Silent Earth: habitat loss; homogenization of agricultural landscapes; overuse of fertilizers; introduction of competitors, predators, and pathogens; disorienting night lights; and, of course, climate change. But leading the list are pesticides and agricultural chemicals more broadly. I was shocked to read that more than seventeen pesticide applications are in use in the crop fields of the UK every year, making it inevitable that much of the countryside is contaminated.
While such prima facie evidence might seem compelling, connecting the dots on the causes of insect decline is a challenge. Critics doubt that chemicals applied locally could have wider impacts across the landscape. But this is what the skeptics said when Rachel Carson raised the alarm about controlling insect populations with DDT. It took ten years of research to demonstrate the persuasive case for DDT’s destructiveness by showing beyond dispute that DDT was bioconcentrating at the top of the food chain and directly causing reproductive failure in bald eagles and other charismatic birds via eggshell thinning.
Meanwhile, DDT, neonicotinoids, paraquat, and other substances banned in Europe and North America continue in widespread use throughout much of the rest of the world. They are so pervasive that “it now seems likely that a large proportion of all the world’s insect species are being chronically exposed to chemicals specifically designed to kill insects,” as Goulson writes.
A book narrowly focused on the evidence linking agrochemicals to insect declines might make for a more ringing call to action, but, as chapter after chapter of Silent Earth makes clear, the multiple, complex, and interacting factors at work in the environment put drawing clear lines of cause and effect in studying insect populations beyond the reach of any one academic research program. Even when the evidence is strong, the political challenge of banning a substance is an asymmetric contest pitting the meager resources of individual groups of academic scientists against the overbearing power of chemicals giants like Bayer-Monsanto and Syngenta.
Fortunately, given the complexity of the science, we have researchers like Goulson who have made a strong commitment to communicating with the public about ground-breaking research with an urgent impact. Goulson writes like a scientist, in a direct and concise manner, drawing us into the arguments while explaining technical points in plain language. In the final chapters he exhorts us to take myriad small actions in our urban and semi-urban habitats to revive and enhance nature, especially pollinators. Plant wildflowers, he urges; mow lawns less often so wildflowers can bloom; construct garden ponds for frogs, newts, and dragonflies; and, especially, instill respect for nature as a foundation in our children’s education. Sharing Goulson’s sympathies, I favor all such efforts individuals can make can make to protect the natural world. But amidst looming global climate and biodiversity crises, persuading one key politician to take a strong stand in favor of the environment will have far greater consequences than the incremental benefit of thousands of individual choices. Ultimately it is the politicians, who have the ability to make policy that can shape whole economies and societies, who will decide through their action or inaction whether our children will live on a habitable planet.
John Terborgh has operated a research field station in the Peruvian Amazon since 1973 and is James B. Duke Professor of Environmental Science and Co-Director of the Center for Tropical Conservation at Duke University. His latest book, co-edited with James A. Estes, is Trophic Cascades: Predators, Prey, and the Changing Dynamics of Nature.
Book Post is a by-subscription book review service, bringing book reviews by distinguished and engaging writers direct to your in-box, as well as free posts from time to time to those who follow us. Thank you for your subscription! Your support supports our writers and our effort to grow a common reading culture across a fractured media landscape. Please help us to grow our audience by sharing this post or cheering us on on social media.
Seminary Co-op and 57th Street Books are Book Post’s Winter 2021 partner bookseller! We partner with independent bookstores to link to their books, support their work, and bring you news of local book life as it happens in their communities. We’ll send a free three-month subscription to any reader who spends more than $100 with our partner bookstore during our partnership. Send your receipt to info@bookpostusa.com.
Follow us: Facebook, Twitter, Instagram
If you liked this piece, please share and tell the author with a “like”